Offline payments and programmability in CBDCs: what have the pilots shown?
By Kumar Shanu · Published · 6 min read
Not legal, tax or investment advice.
Offline CBDC payments let two devices exchange central bank money without a network connection, so a CBDC can work like cash in a village or a power cut. Programmability lets a payment carry rules, such as an expiry date or a list of merchants where it can be spent. India’s e₹ pilot has both, the digital euro plans offline payments but says it will “never be programmable money”, and the BIS found that 98% of central banks see offline use as vital or advantageous.
Indian exporter or freelancer? Payzoplus gets you paid from abroad, in rupees.Open a free account →
On this page
Why do central banks want offline CBDC payments?
Cash works without electricity, a network or a bank’s servers. Most digital payments do not. If a retail CBDC is meant to be a digital form of cash, central banks want it to keep that property. The BIS Innovation Hub’s Project Polaris handbook for offline payments, published on 11 May 2023, cites a BIS survey in which 49% of central banks considered offline payments with a retail CBDC vital and another 49% considered them advantageous. The reasons given were resilience, financial inclusion, privacy and resemblance to cash.
The handbook is also candid about the difficulty. Its finding is that “there is no one-size-fits-all solution”: a design depends on local needs, and the technology, security and operations have to be planned early. Polaris followed up with a high-level design guide for offline payments on 26 October 2023.
Offline and programmable CBDC: key numbers
- 49% + 49%
- Central banks seeing offline as vital / advantageous
- 19
- Banks offering e₹ wallets
- €3,000
- Highest digital euro holding limit the ECB tested
- 0
- Interest on e₹ wallet balances
BIS survey cited in Project Polaris, May 2023
RBI e₹ FAQs, 1 Oct 2026
A hypothesis, not a decision
Cash-like by design
How does an offline CBDC payment work?
In an online payment, the central ledger (or the bank running the wallet) checks that the payer has the money and records the transfer. Offline, there is no ledger to ask. The value has to sit on the device itself, protected so it cannot be copied, and pass directly from one device to another, typically by a tap. The ledger is updated later, when one of the devices reconnects.
An offline payment, step by step
- 1
Load while online
The user moves some CBDC from the online wallet onto the device’s offline balance.
- 2
Tap to pay
Payer and payee devices exchange the value directly, with no network.
- 3
Device checks
Secure software or hardware on each device checks the value is genuine and has not already been spent.
- 4
Sync later
When a device reconnects, the transaction is reported and balances are reconciled.
The hard problem is double spending: without a ledger to check, a tampered device could try to spend the same value twice. Designs answer this with tamper-resistant storage on the device, limits on how much can be held or spent offline, and reconciliation once the device is back online. A cap on the offline balance also caps what any successful attack on one device could create.
What have the pilots shown on offline payments?
India (e₹). In his statement of 8 February 2024, the RBI Governor proposed adding offline capability to the retail pilot for “areas with poor or limited internet connectivity”. The RBI’s e₹ FAQs (updated 1 October 2026) say the offline feature lets users transact with limited or no connectivity and that “different solutions are being explored”. Business Standard reported that an offline e₹, including tap-based NFC payments, was announced at Global Fintech Fest 2025.
Euro area (digital euro). The ECB’s digital euro FAQs describe an offline option in which people would tap their phones together, with a “cash-like level of privacy”: personal transaction details of offline payments “would be known only to the payer and the payee”. This is still a design, not a product. The legislation is under negotiation and a pilot is planned from the second half of 2027; see where the digital euro stands.
Public, independently verified data on how much offline CBDC is actually used are scarce. None of the central banks above publishes offline transaction counts, so this post gives none.
Also readWhat is BIS Project Agorá, who is in it, and how far has it got?What is a programmable CBDC?
Programmability means a rule travels with the money or the payment. The RBI’s FAQs say the e₹ “can be programmed on different parameters like expiry date, geo-location, merchant category codes, merchant VPA, etc.”, and describe programmable wallets for government and corporate use cases, where the money comes with predefined conditions on how it can be used. A state benefit, for example, could be spendable only on fertiliser at registered dealers within a district, and expire at the end of the season. Business Standard reported in October 2025 that programmable e₹ was already being used for targeted subsidies such as Gujarat’s G-SAFAL scheme.
China has gone furthest on the infrastructure side. On 21 October 2026, the PBOC’s E-CNY Operation Management Center announced an upgraded system with a smart contract service framework, integrating issuance, retail and wholesale payments, blockchain and smart contracts. See how big the e-CNY is.
Programmable money or programmable payments?
This is the distinction that matters, and the ECB states it most clearly. It defines programmable money as digital money “for a predefined purpose” with limits on its use, and says “the digital euro would never be programmable money”. What it would allow is conditional payments: a payment that executes automatically when a condition is met, such as paying for an online order only on delivery. The rule sits in the payment, not in the euro itself, and the holder can still spend that euro on anything.
Two kinds of programmability
| Programmable money | Programmable (conditional) payments | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the rule lives | In the money: how, where or when it can be spent | In the payment: when it executes |
| Example | A subsidy usable only at certain merchants, expiring on a date | Pay on delivery; release payment when goods arrive |
| Freedom of the holder | Restricted | Unchanged once the money is received |
| Position in 2026 | Used in India’s e₹ pilot for targeted schemes | Planned for the digital euro; ECB rules out programmable money |
The disagreement is about trust. Supporters see programmable money as a way to make sure subsidies reach their purpose and to cut leakage. Critics worry it lets an issuer control how people spend. The Bank of England’s digital pound pages, for instance, say any future law would guarantee that neither the Bank nor the government could control how people spend their money. A government sponsoring a targeted scheme can program the money it pays out; that is different from programming everyone’s money.
What does this mean for businesses?
| Feature | Most likely first use | What a business would notice |
|---|---|---|
| Offline e₹ | Small payments where connectivity is weak | Another way to accept small payments, alongside UPI and cash |
| Programmable e₹ | Government schemes and corporate spending rules | Receiving payments from scheme beneficiaries at registered outlets |
| Conditional payments | E-commerce, escrow-like flows | Payment released automatically on an agreed event |
| Wholesale smart contracts | Securities and interbank settlement | Nothing directly; faster settlement behind the bank |
For exporters, neither feature changes how foreign clients pay today. Cross-border payments still run through banks and correspondent chains. Programmable settlement between banks, tested in projects such as Project Agorá, is where conditional logic could eventually speed up trade payments, but it remains a test.
How Payzoplus helps you
Getting paid from abroad today
- While CBDCs are piloted, exporters still get paid over bank rails: Payzoplus gives you a USD account in your business name for each customer.
- Your rate is shown beside the mid-market rate before you convert, so you see exactly what the conversion costs.
- Rupees reach your own bank account on T+1 after you reconcile.
No setup fee · No monthly fee · Verification usually takes one working day
Frequently asked questions
Can I use the digital rupee without internet?
The RBI says the offline feature lets users transact with limited or no connectivity and that different solutions are being explored. Availability depends on your bank’s wallet; check with it.
Will the digital euro be programmable?
The ECB says the digital euro would never be programmable money. It would support conditional payments, such as paying automatically on delivery, where the condition sits in the payment rather than in the money.
How is double spending prevented offline?
By storing offline value in tamper-resistant software or hardware on the device, capping offline balances, and reconciling with the ledger once a device reconnects. The BIS says there is no one-size-fits-all solution.
Is programmable e₹ already used?
Yes, in pilots. The RBI’s FAQs describe programmable wallets for government and corporate use cases, and Business Standard reported its use for targeted subsidies such as Gujarat’s G-SAFAL scheme.
Sources
The primary texts this article was checked against, on 30 October 2026.
- BIS Innovation Hub — Project Polaris: handbook for offline payments with CBDC (11 May 2023)
- BIS Innovation Hub — Project Polaris project page
- RBI — Frequently asked questions on the Digital Rupee (e₹), updated 1 October 2026
- RBI — Statement on Developmental and Regulatory Policies (8 February 2024)
- ECB — Digital euro FAQs
- Business Standard — RBI’s offline digital rupee is here (13 October 2025)
- CGTN (Xinhua) — China upgrades digital yuan system to expand payment, smart contract services (22 October 2026)
- Bank of England — The digital pound
General information, not tax, legal or investment advice. Rules and products change: confirm the details for your business with your CA, your bank or the regulator.
How useful was this article?
Be the first to rate it.

Comments
Be kind and stay on topic. Comments with links or contact details are checked before they appear.